BookWorthy
Looking for books your kids will love — and you can trust?
The award-winning BookWorthy Podcast is your weekly guide to help Christian parents cut through the noise and find books that actually matter. Each week, award-winning children's author Valerie Fentress chats with authors about stories that help kids process big feelings, grow in faith, and see God’s goodness in everyday life.
Think of it as your trusted book buddy for raising readers who love Jesus.
Full Transcripts available at http://www.valeriefentress.com/blog
BookWorthy
An Interactive Adventures Series for Kids with Kathryn Butler
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode, children's author Kathryn Butler discusses her innovative Lamplight series, which combines interactive storytelling with biblical principles to engage young readers. She shares insights into her writing process, the spiritual themes woven into her stories, and her journey from medicine to children's literature.
See this episode blog post here: www.valeriefentress.com/blog
Chapters
00:00 Introduction to the Lamplighter Series
03:56 Interactive Fiction and Biblical Wisdom
07:16 Exploring The Hunt for the Kraken
09:51 Journey to Escape from Rome
11:10 Transitioning from Dream Keeper to Lamplighter
17:19 The Role of Literature in Shaping Faith
20:10 From Trauma Surgeon to Writer
26:18 Looking Ahead: Future Projects
Let's discover great books together!
Follow for more:
FB: @bookworthypodcast
Instagram: @bookworthy_podcast
YouTube: BookWorthy Podcast - YouTube
tiktok: @valeriefentress
This transcript has been lightly edited for clarity but reflects the full conversation from the BookWorthy Podcast. Grab a cup of coffee, listen, and read along.
The blog version of this episode is available at www.valeriefentress.com/blog
Valerie - Welcome to Bookworthy, where we discover children's books, board books, and YA that your kids will love and you can trust. Today, we're talking with trauma surgeon turned writer and homeschooling mom, the lovely Kathryn Butler. She is the author of the amazing Dream Keeper Saga, which could be a whole episode in itself. But today we're talking about her latest middle-grade project, the Lamplighter series. So far, there are two books available: The Hunt for the Kraken, a high-seas adventure, and Escape from Rome, a blast to the past.
In these immersive novels, the reader is the protagonist. So each suspenseful chapter ends with two or three courses of action, and kids choose one and see where the story takes them. Bible verses throughout reassure readers that, wherever the outcome, whether good or bad, God is with them. And as kids have fun steering the crew or facing the Coliseum through these action-packed adventures, they'll also learn how to apply biblical wisdom and rely on God's grace. I can't wait to hear more about this series.
Welcome to BookWorthy, Kathryn.
Kathryn - Thank you so much for having me, Valerie. It's a real joy to be here.
Valerie - It's great to have you. You were a part of our Middle Grade March Madness back in March. It was kind of one of those pipe dreams, like, maybe I could get Kathryn to join. So we had some dancing at our house when you joined that.
Kathryn - It's my pleasure. I was saying, I think it's wonderful that you're, you know, that you're just introducing families to a bunch of different authors and books all for, you know, Christ's glory. And so thank you for what you've done and for your service.
Valerie - It has been my joy. But to get us started, we have to do our random question of the week. So if you can visit any country right now, like beam me up, Scotty, to said location, where would you go?
Random Question of the Week
Kathryn - Yeah, so I struggled because I have a real soft spot in my heart for Ireland because it's where my heritage is, and my husband and I were the first place where we traveled, and I just think there's something idyllic, and it feels like a hint of heaven to be out in the countryside in Ireland. So part of my heart is always there. But my daughter and I just finished reading about Stonehenge, and I think it would be really cool to take my kids to England and look at all the medieval sites and just soak in. There's so much history there that we just don't see here in the US. And so I think that's where I would go if it had to be right this moment, I had to choose. yeah. just like I remember big years ago going, and you're walking through London, and you'll see a rock or a building, and it's like, this is from the year 1322.
Valerie - It's a good choice. The Salisbury Plain is beautiful.
Kathryn - That's 500 years earlier than anything around me. So, right? Oh gosh, and like the bard used to be here. Then, know, it's just, so I think that would be really just fun as an adventure as a family.
Valerie - Most definitely. I hope you get the chance to do that with them, because it would be fun. Okay. I think I would probably tag along on your trip. Because yeah, Ireland and Scotland and England are definitely favorites of mine. It was kind of my husband and my European trip before we started having kids to go to Ireland for a few days. And that was just fun. Just fun.
Kathryn - Where did you go?
Valerie - So we were in Northern Ireland. So I was writing a book on kind of the Irish conflict, the IRA, and just the Catholic Protestant division that's in that country. And so we went to Armagh, which is where the story was set. And so we went up to Dublin, and we kind of just kind of, didn't do the normal Ireland tour. We kind of did our own thing, which was kind of the way we do things.
Kathryn - Oh, wow. So it was boots on the ground research for your book, then.
Valerie - It was boots on the ground, so it was fun. Well, Katherine, why don't you tell us a little bit about this new series, the Lamplight series?
Kathryn Butler’s Lamplight Series- a decide-as-you-go adventure
Kathryn - Yeah, that's the lamp light series. So, back when, I don't know if you were my generation, but back in the 80s and the 90s, there were the Choose Your Own Adventure books that were really popular, which we all devoured because you get to be the protagonist of the story, and it's written in second person, and you get to choose where the story goes. So cross with my publisher, actually, Amy Cruz, who's one of the acquisition editors and the head of author relations. It was actually her idea, where she reached out and said, What if we did this for Christian kids? And I said, yes, that sounds lovely. So the idea is that it's the same idea. It's interactive fiction. So it's a decide-as-you-go adventure. And the kids decide where they want the story to go. But what we did differently, here's the first one. So it's called The Hunt for the Kraken, which is the first one. For every choice that you make, the next chapter that you go to opens with a Bible passage. And it's often from Psalms or from Proverbs.
Some of them are obvious, some are less so. But the idea is to kind of take kids on a whirlwind adventure where they get swept up, where they can go back and make different choices and see what happens, and hopefully inform them a little bit in terms of biblical principles as they go. And what I really liked about the concept and the idea, and what I hope it does too, is that it conveys to kids that choices are hard. Sometimes the right choice is not obvious.
Sometimes we have no right choice, sometimes there's no good choice. But as long as we're trying to remain faithful to what God has taught us in his word, he's always delighted in that. And that, most importantly, that we always have forgiveness in Christ. So I'm hoping to portray those principles through the instrument of an adventurous, fun story.
Valerie - I love it. I grew up in the eighties and nineties. So yeah, those are, you know, choose your own adventure books were huge. And we tried to get my kids into reading them, and we went to the library, and there were like 12. That was all there was. We're like, there's got to be more of these. And, but I mean, they devoured them and, because it is, it's you're taking control. You're in the story. You're part of it, which is all part of the process. But, and then to have to make the choice. Do I go left or do I go right? And that's why we face those choices every day, but for them to see how those actions lead to consequences, both positive and negative. And I love how you're bringing in, you know, Bible verses and just God's wisdom throughout just to ground kids nowadays in that our choices can have a source of answer. So we don't have to, we're not doing this alone. We don't have like, I don't know if I go to medical school or I go to art school, which one am I going to do? God can use you in either choice, either way. And even when we do make mistakes, his mercies renew every morning, and he can make sense of the mess.
Kathryn- Yes, His grace is sufficient?
Valerie -Too fun. Exactly. Thank you. Okay, so tell us a little bit about the hunt for the Kraken.
The Heart Behind The Hunt for the Kraken
Kathryn - Sure, so it begins with the protagonist, and this was obviously inspired by my own experience because I'm in Boston and my family loves to fish. There, as is true for many authors, there's some of my own experience in this. The protagonist is out on a jetty near Boston Harbor, fishing with his or her dad, and is frustrated because nothing's biting on the line, and then sees a strange blue light in the lighthouse nearby. And the basic premise for all the books is that there is a blue light, which, as you read, you'll find out is connected to God's word, that transports the protagonist to another time and another place. So in the hunt for the Kraken, it whisks him or her away to the North Sea in the 1800s. The protagonist finds him or herself on a ship out in the middle of the ocean run by a corrupt pirate who has the crew there under the auspices that they're wailing, but in reality, he's searching for the Kraken, almost in a Captain Ahab premise of revenge. So there is a series of events that happen, and what do you do? Do you help the pirate? Do you corroborate with him? Do you try to escape? What happens when you escape when different monsters start showing up? It's real fun just romping, and there are monsters, there's intrigue, there's mystery, there's hard choices, and hopefully also some guiding light of his word throughout.
Valerie - I love it. For my kids, the mascot at our school system is the pirates. And so it is hilarious to watch my kids like, all right, it's dressed like a pirate day. Let's do this. And so what kid doesn't want to be on a pirate ship, you know, exploring. So, I love that. I bet.
Kathryn - Yeah. It was fun for me. I was enjoying being on the pirate ship.
Valerie - We all want to sail the mighty seas, right?
Kathryn - Exactly, right. I want to do this. Arr, I'm going to start talking like this, you know?
Valerie - I think in November it's Talk Like a Pirate Day, one of those days that's always fun. My kids are like, Oh, it must be Talk Like a Pirate day. I'm like, yes.
Kathryn - Then the question is how long you can let that go, and what professional context can you get away with it before people start giving you strange looks, and then your job is at stake.
Valerie - It happens really fast. So when my kids are younger, and we go to the grocery store, I don't know why I chose to go to the grocery store on Talk Like a Pirate Day, but there was definitely some laughing in the other aisles when my kids were talking, and it's good fun. But okay. Tell us a little bit about escape from Rome. You take us from the 1800s all the way to 60 AD with Nero. So tell us.
The Heart Behind Kathryn Butler’s Escape from Rome
Kathryn - Yeah, yeah. The premise of that one is that the protagonist is working in his or her aunt's dusty museum and gets whisked away to Rome during the era of Emperor Nero, right before the great fire. And so winds up appearing in the Colosseum, where there's a lion attacking a gladiator and needing to decide what to do to get out of that situation. And then the great fire spreads out, and then what do you do then? And so that's the premise there. And for that one, I tried to also weave in some elements of Christian history, talking about the persecution of the Christians under Nero. So that's hopefully something that if kids are talking with their parents or you're reading this as a family, you could talk about that this was something that was a part of the past.
Valerie - Now these two books seem like a very big shift from the Dream Keeper saga. And you kind of mentioned that Crossway came to you with the idea. What was it like going from this portal fantasy to almost another type of portal fantasy in a sense, but with a little bit more contemporary vibes? What was the shift?
Kathryn - Yeah, it wasn't. It was the hardest thing, which I think you could probably imagine, the plot structure. In my writing process, when they talk about fiction, they're either a plotter, meaning that you outline everything ahead of time, or you're a pantser. So you fly by the seat of your pants. I'm a pantser. So for me to get to know my characters and know what the book is about, I have to be writing. So that was a challenge when I then sat down, and every few pages, the plot changes. That was the biggest challenge. But once I figured out the rhythm of it and what would work, which for me was actually writing three story threads to their completion and then going back and writing the branch points, that allowed me to get to know the characters well enough that I could then see where things would go. Once I did that, it was similar.
I think people who are familiar with the Dream Keeper Saga will see similarities in that when I wrote the Dream Keeper Saga, one of the very prominent themes in my mind throughout it was hope in the darkness, and allegorically speaking, about the hope of Christ that carries us through the darkness. And that's the same in these books. Some of the endings are bad because the reality is that in a real world with real dangers, bad things will happen.
Valerie - Some of the endings are because the reality is that in the world, if you do this, things don't happen. But I tried to speak only in the first moments, but God.
Kathryn - But I tried to still cling to it in those moments, but God knows, we're fallen. We need rescue, but God still loved us so that he sent his son. So I think people who are familiar with the dream people will see that same element in these, although it's not going to be as well developed, obviously. So I think it was relatively easy to get a little bit of a for Although it's kind of just a little bit of a pain. I kind of like how you explained that. I was thinking through how you plan, cause I'm a I'm a planner and a pantser. So I'll make a plan. I'll start writing. And then the characters decided I'm going to be a pantser for the other half of it. And so it was like, I can't even, I can't even imagine giving my characters multiple options.
How Kathryn Butler went about writing a Decide as You Go Story
Kathryn - Yeah, it was. That was the hardest part. And so it really had to be that I had to do where I'm just saying, okay, I'm just gonna write as if this is a story. And I did that for three threads. And then that at least gave me enough time spent in the world and with the characters to have an idea. And then it was okay. Then I was able to bounce in and out, and it was fine. But that was, and then I used an Excel file where I like to map everything, and there are arrows, and my editor cannot even look at the manuscript unless I send the map. For the second book, she's like, I didn't get the map, where's the map? So that was the challenge. And I think, because that's my process too. Some familiar people, and I say, choose your adventure, that's trademarked. So I'm saying like, choose your adventure like books from the eighties and nineties, that they tended to be really, really short chapters. They are longer because that's more of how I approach fiction, as I want to kind of draw readers in. So it's not going to be as many transitions as it is in those books. But I still have like 12 to 13 endings in each of the books. So there's enough of a branching, but I had to make things a little longer for me to be able to feel like I could write a story that flowed.
Valerie -I can understand that because yeah, those, those eighties and nineties books definitely, it was very fast paced and you know, like, hold on, I need to breathe a minute.
Kathryn - Right, and my brain does not work that way, unfortunately. So I need to spend a little bit more time with each scene.
Valerie - I remember like reading aloud one of those, and like we went two pages and then made a decision, and we died. Like, we got another 20 minutes to come up with another way to fix this. But I love how you're wanting, you know, readers to engage with these characters, see these characters as kind of like, okay, what would, to look ahead, to kind of think, okay, what are the choices I have to make in my daily life? And how can my choices have positive and negative effects? And I think your ability to create these amazing characters that you did in Dream Keeper Sago holds in this series, so that kids can really enjoy the journey that these characters are going on, and really enjoy being the protagonist of their own story in one sense.
Kathryn Butler Shares the Power of Stories
Kathryn - Yeah, right. love, know, and I guess, since you probably would agree, the same. I love that stories can have that heart training for kids, where it's a safe space, right? And they can encounter hard questions, hard realities that they're going to see in daily life in some way as they grow. And it will not be on the North Sea, but the questions, you know, about betrayal and anger and fear and grief that we all deal with, feel like literature is a wonderful instrument for kids to ask questions about those and put their heads around it, but do it in a way that's safe so that then what we've got in life, like they're equipped and have a core of understanding about God's work in the world. It's just a meaningful challenge.
Valerie- I can't remember the quote exactly, but you know, reading as an active teaching empathy and to walk in someone else's shoes. And I think it's such a great gift to give kids, you know, books that present so many different choices and so many different personalities. That, you know, caused they're always be like that. We had some bullying situations with the kids where they're like in the third grade, and it's like, This doesn't really change, buddy. I'm sorry. Cause it's it's one of those, like there will be mean kids throughout your life. And let's, let's pray through this. Let's work through this and to give you the tools to process this well, not take their words to heart, and know where your identity lies. And so it's like, that's like in that crucible of angst is where our kids' faith is going to grow. And if we can kind of present that in different ways, especially in great books like yours, we can equip them for the crazy world we live in.
Kathryn -Absolutely. And I'll say that resonates so much, Valerie, and I'll be honest, the Dream Keeper Saga came about because I saw that at work in my own kids in real time. And it was, I don't know if you've heard me talk about this before, but it was during COVID, and I was asked to go back and help out in the hospital. I had left home, I had left practice to homeschool. But our ICUs in Boston were overrun, and I was ICU trained.
So, my partner asked me to come back. And my son was seven, and he was old enough to be scared. Where I was very early in the pandemic. He was worried about me getting sick. We didn't know anything about transmissibility at that point. And he started to really question God's goodness and ask, like, why is God allowing this to happen? And the key moment, we did all the things that you should, meaning we went, we talked with about him with Job and we read John 11 about, you know, Jesus waiting and letting Lazarus die so that those could gather around, could then see him resurrected and see that he was the, you Jesus was the Christ. All of those things helped him to contextualize suffering. But the moment when it clicked was when we were reading The Return of the King. And there's that scene when Minas Tirith is being besieged. And the way Tolkien writes it, it's just that the gloom has overtaken all of Middle-earth, and it's despair, and there's no hope. And then the writers of Rohan come sweeping down the plane, and the language changes, the atmosphere changes. There's a wind off the sea and dawn breaks, and you've realized that good will overcome. And my son and I started crying, and he said, those were such beautiful words. Can you read them again? And I did. And I said, " You know what this reminds me of? I'm like, this reminds me of the fact that no matter what we're dealing with right now and how dark it seems, Christ has already overcome. And because we hope in him, we don't need to despair about this. No. And you came to faith after that. And so seeing that in our own lives, about literature and books have this ability to shepherd our kids in God's word, when we choose stories that have gospel themes, and we're reading the Bible along with them, to me, it's just such a gift. And so that same night, when I was on my way to the hospital, I had a picture in my head of a girl walking in on a dragon in her kitchen. And that's how the gym keeper saga happened. Right, that's what it was. So instead of swatting away the image like I normally would do because I'm a grown-up, I instead said, " Okay, let me start asking questions. Why is there a dragon? Who is this girl? Why is he eating chili? And that's how it evolved.
Valerie - I love that. did kind of want to ask you, what was that transition from trauma hospital to writer? And you kind of gave a little bit there in that description of your interaction with your son, but how did you make that? I mean, that's a big shift.
Acts of Obedience and Submission in Kathryn Butler’s Writing Journey
Kathryn - Yeah, honestly, though, it's interesting because medicine was the first big shift away from writing. Writing was my first love. It's what I always thought I would do. I wrote my first book when I was 17 and got a college scholarship. I went to writers' conferences in high school. Like that's what I was set to do. And then the Lord steered me in a completely different direction when my dad survived a heart attack. And it just brought to my mind, like, wow, this is an amazing way to help other people.
It would be to go into medicine. So he saw the Lord guided me toward medicine, and I don't regret it at all. It was a real privilege, but then when my son was three, my daughter was about nine months old. For several reasons that became very clear that I couldn't stay. I couldn't stay and remain faithful to like Deuteronomy 6 6 to 7 really convicted me because it was clear that I was not able to shepherd my kids in the Lord's word daily and still work. And I'm not saying that that means that moms can't work. It was me specifically. I did a very bad job of creating boundaries, and my work was honestly an idol. And so what I've seen since then is that really the breaking down of idols in my heart really faces that belong to him. instead had stuff with my own pride and
Kathryn Butler (23:08.5)
My own desire to succeed and to be accomplished in the eyes of the world. So it was a real sanctifying move. Then, as a result, the writing just felt like coming home. And I started writing on, because I was wrestling with things that I'd seen in the hospital and trying to contextualize it through a Christian lens, and started then saying, try to, I put together these, one of being articles, like reflections, and I'd been reading Desiring God at the time. So I reached out to them and said, would anybody benefit from this? And that's what happened. It just snowballed.
Valerie - That's amazing. I love how God is always working on us. As you said, you decide as you go, the decisions we make, God is working with them and in them, and working on our hearts. We're never done this side of heaven. And I love that in your own story, it's been, you've seen God's faithfulness at each turn and God's willingness to continue to work on us. Cause I think our kids need to know that also. And they need to know that God loves them individually, not just as the church, but they also are loved so intimately that God wants to walk with us through the good times and through the bad times, and the choices, the choices we make, cause I have a similar story. I was like pre-vet school, and you know, kind of science, cancer research, all these things. And God said, " Nope. He was like, " That's your idea, not mine”.
Kathryn - Right, wow, that had to be tremendously humbling for you too, to say, okay, this is what I thought, but I'm saying no.
Valerie - Yes. Yes. When you get laid off every six months for every science job because of most, not because of my work ethic, but because of budget cuts and that kind of thing. You're like, okay, God, you're telling me something. What are you telling me? So God has been faithful to hit me over the head a few times and to keep me moving.
Kathryn - Yeah. Have you found, though, that the thing is that God doesn't waste anything? So, have you found in your own transition? Have you seen him at work through it?
Valerie- What is it? I've seen him work in my heart, and being able to lean on faith. I haven't so much, there's been no really, I haven't written any science things in a long time, but it's one of those like, God's definitely been in the process of working on my heart to being brave enough to step out in faith and to say, okay, I'm going to be obedient, God, you get to do the rest. And so that's been really sweet.
Kathryn - Right, right, and refining, I'll bet.
Valerie - Most definitely. But it's also been good for my kids, too, to see. I chose one direction because they're all like in school, and a lot is coming at them to say, you need to decide what you're going to be when you grow up and you have to choose now. And it's like, nah.
Kathryn - You know what? It might not even be up to us. Exactly.
Valerie -- And now God's going to direct you where you need to go. And even if you choose something different, he's going to use you wherever you go. And so it's been very great as a parenting tool to be like, yeah, you know that, you know, so that standardized tests you have to take. I feel that. And I, I still survived. And so it's, it's, it's been good to just kind of communicate to my kids that God is always working on us. What the world says is, you know, the perfect box doesn't exist. And so it's been fun.
Kathryn - Right, right, right. I think that's so, what a freeing message for you to be able to give them. When I imagine just the pressures of school and accomplishments and everything else is telling them the opposite, you're almost offering a visual lived-out reminder of Ephesians 2 10. know, word God's workmanship created in Christ Jesus for good works that he prepared ahead of time is determined what we're going to do. It's glorifying to him. But that's beautiful that you can give them that example.
Valerie - It's been very freeing for me, and I have a couple of kids with some learning disabilities. To be like, even with dyslexia or ADHD, know, God knows these things about you. It's not a surprise. He knows that the decision as you go is going to follow him, and he's going to work with you because he made you so exactly.
Kathryn - Amen. Right, you belong to him. You are his. And he's upholding you.
Valerie - What is your favorite book, Katie?
Kathryn Butler’s Favorite Book
Kathryn Butler (28:03.166)
I hate all the books. I hate this question.
Valerie - You could pack for your trip to Stonehenge. You could only take one book, and this book you will have to give to somebody when you arrive. Can only be one book. Yes, it could be a trilogy. Well, okay. Yes, that's technically it was written as a full book. I'll give you that one because the author originally intended for it to be one book.
Kathryn - Well, technically... Okay, Lord of the Rings. Was technically published as a trilogy but written as one book. If I only had one book to read, that would be it.
Valerie - Yes. Most definitely. Okay, what can we expect next from you?
Coming Soon from Kathryn Butler
Kathryn - Yeah, so the third book in the Lamplight series will be coming out sometime in 2027. It's called Mission to Io. So it's taking us to outer space. And then for the parents out there, this is a completely different direction. But I was asked to write Jonnie Erikson Tada's Authorized Biography, which will also be coming out in the summer of 2027. So that's been a huge joy and a privilege. And that I'm just delighted and excited about. I'm wrapping up the manuscript right now, and that'll be out shortly after this comes out.
Valerie - That must have been an amazing experience.
Kathryn - It was, it was just, you you're even talking about God being at work and God being sovereign and having and that's her entire life is what you see of God working through her accident, both to bring about this tremendous ministry that has touched so many of the suffering, but also in her own life of just winnowing her and sanctifying her and pressing her in the midst of her suffering deeper and deeper into fellowship with Christ. And so it was just a tremendous privilege to do it.
Valerie - Okay, it's on my TBR. I'll be reading that. Let's go. Add to cart. Well, Katie, where can people find out more about you and your books?
How to Connect with Kathryn Butler
Kathryn - Sure, so I do, I keep a blog. I don't write on it very much. It's mostly a landing page for people to get in touch with me. But I do list my book titles there. And that's KatherineButler.com, real easy to remember. For my books, too, you can always go to CrossWave's website. They are my main publisher. And you can go under the author link there, and you can find a list of most of my books. But please do reach out. You can reach out to my publicist. I love corresponding with people over email. So I'm delighted to hear from anyone.
Valerie - I love it. We'll make sure to have those links in the show notes and the blog version of this, also. Thank you so much for being with me today, Katie.
Katie- Thank you, thank you so much for having me on, Valerie. It was a joy.
Valerie - It's been a pleasure, and thank you for joining Kathryn and me on this episode of the Bookworthy Podcast. If you follow wherever you're listening and leave a review to help other Christian families discover more great books your kids will love and you can trust. The blog version of this episode, with all the links and books we discussed, can be found at ValerieFentress.com slash blog.
Happy reading.